Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | pseudony's commentslogin

You seem to forget that there is a rather large world outside of the US - and we very much would be better off with non-gated, open weights models.

And what do you base this on ?

How does one objectively quantify how it stacks upnto another model ?

Or even, what is your subjective evaluation based on ?

I really wonder - because I have just finished a fully vibe-coded gtk/rust/lua application with me basically writing 7% of the code (all in one module) and GLM 5.1 writing the rest. We haven’t had regressions, confusion or anything else. And I am pretty damned sure I couldn’t manage this one year ago with claude code and Sonnet.


You don’t need a fancy kill switch, just stop sending parts and updates, any sustained conflict will do the work.

Any F35 bought by Europe is nothing short of lunacy. You don’t buy from people hell-bent on having conflicts with you.


The UK alone produces 15% of the parts required to assemble the F35. Around 25% of the jet is manufactured/produced by the other partners of the program.

Heck the F35B only exists due to the UK demanding it. They have access to the source code (and so do Israel).


Due to political engineering some significant parts are manufactured in partnership countries. That supply chain is also a vulnerability for the US albeit to a lesser degree.

Excatly and even more they are stripped version. Export version is always inferior.

Except the Israeli versions obviously. These are at least on par with domestic.

Iam not sure about this, may be true. But in general exported products are always less capable. Be it f35, brahmos or s400.

Congratulations :)

As a Dane, I would say yes. Especially among boomers there was always a genuine appreciation of the US and its role as guardian of a rules-based international order and western civilization more generally.

I think that sentiment has gone, even as younger generations have increasingly incorporated English words, music, TV and more into their own, but you seldom hear the same genuine trust in the US as a force for good.


I'd say in Norway there's more inherent trust in America. People may appear a bit more critical, but by now it's part of the culture. Even though you have some regresion of that trust due to Trump and polarization, I'd say most people see the US as a core part of Western society, cultural and critical to defense.


Yes, it is all a conspiracy.

Or. Have you considered that the erstwhile closest military ally of the US increasingly diversifying AWAY from US programs actually is pretty noteworthy. You have had canadians boycotting US products, cancel trips to the US, their PM encouraging elbows up attitude and delivering a pretty noteworthy speech in Davos about charting a course for middle powers and you think it’s business as usual?


Wrong - I am very far from a catholic, but this just doesn’t reflect history.

They did a lot to make the middle ages more tolerable. After that, maybe they overstayed their welcome.


He didn’t say that. He said that he agrees with the pope on this issue. You don’t become a catholic from agreeing on an issue


Sure — we can play that game. Worked for a state org in an EU country too.

I disagree, I note that multiple countries have digital ministries drafting plans to drop Microsoft products or to begin a wholesale migration due to sovereignty and security.

Once something becomes policy at the highest levels, the individual orgs will have to follow, even if slowly.

I really think you are grossly misreading the last 12 months or so. There is a big difference between a municipality migration as a cost-saving move and the very state saying declaring a national security threat from foreign-based vendors.


Definitely. And then one could start wondering if the direction might reverse.


It would take something miraculous for the direction to reverse towards Europe. People have been complaining about European tech, economy, and freedoms (as in free speech) for decades now. Things have become worse on all of these fronts.

I think the AI act is a great example here. The EU came up with regulation for an emerging technology that basically killed the chance for Europe to compete. Lots of people disagreed with this criticism when the act was debated, but it turns out the critics were right. Europe will be buying AI services from elsewhere because Europe wasn't able to compete.

This entire way of thinking in Europe would need to reverse for there to be a chance that the brain drain changes course.


On the flip side, with the US cutting funding for scientific research, and increasing persecution of minorities within the US, I know a whole bunch of qualified scientists/researchers who are either moving to or actively hunting for a position in the EU


Really not many people outside far right proponents of hate speech (and more recently MAGA shills) have been complaining about free speech in Europe. Yes, there are laws against holocaust denial for specific historical reasons. The UK also had regulations on some Irish republican organisations access to TV, but not other forms of expression. And yes most European jurisdictions accept that speech can cause harm and try to balance this against free speech. But there is really no case that nonviolent political speech is -- in practice -- discriminated against in EU and UK.

On the IT and AI services: Europe hasn't really failed to compete in innovation, as much as scale of operation. That might change if we have a security imperative to protect our own markets for these things against an increasingly hostile US.


People have been fined and their apartments searched for insulting politicians online.

The fact that other Europeans aren't complaining about this makes it worse, because it implies that the society condones this behavior.

I'm sorry, but in no sensible society should the police raid someone's home because he called the deputy chancellor (think vice president) a dumbass on Twitter ("dummkopf"). Or more recently: police started investigating a man for calling Merz (the chancellor) Pinocchio:

https://www.yahoo.com/news/articles/german-police-probe-face...

>but not other forms of expression.

France - fined for calling Macron a "scumbag":

https://www.lemonde.fr/en/m-le-mag/article/2023/04/23/french...

UK - teenager sentenced for a "hate crime" for posting rap lyrics on Instagram:

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-merseyside-43816921

This applies to other European countries too.


to europe? hardly. maybe to east asia ...



Look at what he does now, you honestly think a person this greedy would ever exercise less than maximum control?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: