Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

A statement with absolutely zero backing. Readability did the analysis and certainly seemed to believe that Android supported their product. Marco doesn't do analysis but instead just parrots the standard rhetoric, seemingly hoping that his words alone will make Android irrelevant and thus unnecessary of effort. His loss.

1) You forgot that lots of other companies also did the same analysis as Readability and concluded that the Android is not for them, at least for the moment. You can find several such statements on web pages, and a lot more that speak through their actions.

2) You also forget that Readability and Instapaper don't have the exact same business model.

3) Lastly, you forget that Marco makes his own business decisions, and he bases them on his own insights. He doesn't have to do anything he doesn't want to. Would you go lend him a hand for free on the Android version? Even the overhead of dealing with an extra developer to do the port and the support etc, might be something he doesn't want to deal with, whatever the money. (Why should he? Just because some people are bitter that the don't have his app on their platform of choice, or more general, that they don't get a lot of the cool the apps the iOS market has?)

If Marco is content with his choice, then it's not "his loss", as he does not lose anything.



Lastly, you forget that Marco makes his own business decisions

How so? I didn't forget that whatsoever. Many devs do make individual choices to support only one platform or another, for many reasons (business reasons, bias, etc). That's life.

The person I responded to claimed that Arment had empirical reasons for his claims. Hardly. Arment is a cheerleader of the worst kind, with little professionalism about the market as a whole.


Professionalism lies in delivering a good product and keeping YOUR customers happy.

It has nothing to do with market research etc. You can say he is not "market savvy" maybe, but not unprofessional.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: