Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I'm curious as to what questions it actually raises? There was, a long time ago, someone who has now left as COO. The WMF (which the article consistently calls "Wikipedia") runs quite an open operation. Sue Gardener put in excellent processes into place and the organization is quite a tight ship by all accounts.

Probably there are some stuff ups. It's a non-profit. The business cards issue sounds like one of those. That's something that can happen with any organization, so not sure if that's enough to see some sort of nefarious scheme conning people out of their money...

Of all the issues that Orlowski could nit-pick on, he chose the most ridiculous. There's nothing to see here, just a bunch of assertions with no evidence or even earth shattering revelations.

Frankly, the article is a hatchet job. Bravo El Reg, a quality publication!



I hate the Register and I haven't read the article.

So, ignoring that article: You have some knowledge of Wikimedia, and Wikipedia, and the foundation. What problems do you think those projects have, and how could they overcome those problems?

I ask in the spirit of learning, not bashing.


To be honest, it's been a very long time since I was an active participant on Wikipedia. The issues I had we're always with Wikipedia, and almost never the regulars (except Giano, who I notice has now left the project). I never had an issue with anyone from the WMF, they were always very professional.

The few issues I did have were based on unsubstantiated rumour, so I'm not about to repeat them here, suffice to say that those perceived or real issues were cleaned up a long time ago.


>> I'm curious as to what questions it actually raises?

One could just post a link to the article and ask his opinion. I'm sure he would respond.


No thanks. He'll probably fabricate something I've said, as he did with Robert Scoble. [1]

1. http://thomashawk.com/2005/11/andrew-orlowski-and-register-b...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: