Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Syncing all devices is fundamentally wrong and broken. Apple won't get it right until they drop the concept.

Try controlling what music from your vast library is currently on your tiny iphone. It's a god damned nightmare. Apple wants to "sync" which is just the wrong paradigm.

My phone is not synced with my itunes library. It's just contains a very small subset of it. If I were to draw a Venn diagram of "all the things" it would contain my iphone5, iphone4, ipad3, macbook, other icloud data, plus data on Apple's servers about what apps and TV shows I own but currently do not exist on any device in my possession. Each circle in the diagram has varying degrees of overlap with all the other circles. Not a single one is fully contained in any other. To proclaim that all of these devices are "fully synced" is just plain wrong.



This is where Google's Play Music works much better - your music is in the cloud by default, but you can "pin" specific albums to have them stored on the device.

If you play some song that's not on the device, it will be streamed and then cached for some time till space runs out.


This is how iCloud works already, if all your music was bought from iTunes or if you're using iTunes match




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: