Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It is refreshing to find an article with a false title that contains it's own refutation within the first five paragraphs:

"The only career in which a high school graduate can expect to continue to work on [problems with a unique correct answer] is academic research in pure mathematics"

Unfortunately for this article, the premise that mathematics is the same thing as engineering is false.

If an engineering problem does not have a unique solution, its because of complications introduced by the real world. Any engineering problem which can be well-posed as a pure math problem, does of course have a unique solution; as the author concedes.



It depends on what you mean by a math problem. It seems a common idea is: A math problem is a question asking for the set of solutions to some mathematical equation, and only the actual solution is useful.

But I would include all of the following as math problems: -Prove that some equation actually has solutions -Find some bounds on solutions to that equation -How can I compute an approximate solution to that equation? -How good is that approximation going to be? -What's a way to try to separate large data sets into clusters?

With regards to the first four: many equations people are interested in simply have no hope of getting a solution you can write down. Simple example: sqrt(2). A more complicated example: solutions to the Navier-Stokes equations.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: