Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I don't think violent revolt is quite necessary. We certainly seem to be seeing a non-violent revolt happening in the entertainment industry. People, unhappy with the way the music and movie industry have been trying to leverage their monopolistic power over certain franchises, have turned to non-violently pirating media, to the point that, for a lot of people, and many properties, the easiest mode of obtaining them is piracy.

Étienne de La Boétie wrote in one of his earliest writings 'Discourse on Voluntary Servitude"[0] that tyrants only have power because people voluntarily give it. All that the people must do to overthrow the tyrant is to just sit down on the ground and give up helping him, because the tyrant has no true power of his own.

One of the more reassuring aspects about the Internet and the global economy is that ideas can spread in an instant, and it really enables people to be able to freely associate, even in many cases despite their governments' express attempts to prevent them from doing so. I think the Internet is growing a sense of global community, where it's a lot harder for the average joe to think of someone on the other side of the planet as a faceless enemy, specifically because it puts a face on people.

And it also allows us to trade with so much more ease. It doesn't matter if it's in dollars or bitcoins or euros or whatever. Currency is whatever is convenient. And the technology we have today makes it incredibly more convenient than ever before.

So in sum total, I think it means that it's so much easier today to just ignore the tyrants and go about life in your own way, on your own terms. The more people do that, the less support the tyrants have, until they either capitulate to be able to capture at least some of the pie for themselves, or starve to death.

[0] granted, the full text is a bit childish in its view of the world, but I think there are some decent take-aways to be had.



> All that the people must do to overthrow the tyrant is to just sit down on the ground and give up helping him, because the tyrant has no true power of his own.

I think the fear here is that at some point the relevant servants of the tyrant will all be technological constructs unable of sitting down. If we're really careful about making sure our robot army doesn't revolt then what happens when a tyrant controls them?


I would call that a phobia, not a fear.


That's because it is easy to pirate music.

There are plenty of people who are unhappy with the way that banks have and continue to behave. It is however a bit more difficult to help yourself to some of the money in the banks even if you feel justified to.


If one person owns all the dollars then dollars become useless as a medium of exchange. People have always and will continue to figure out their own currencies when the official one fails them.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: